I am sometimes asked whether a modern seal should be used where the original seal was metal/leather.
A modern seal can be used but only if the shaft the seal is sealing to has a suitable surface finish. If for example the shaft is a new axle shaft this will probably be OK. If the shaft has any imperfections a leather seal will usually seal better as the lip of a leather seal is wider than a modern neoprene seal. If the shaft is made of a soft material a modern seal can wear a groove in the surface for the same reason.
Before fitment of leather seals a little preparation will help get the best results.